Medical Council of Canada MCCQE Part 1 MCCQE Question # 19 Topic 2 Discussion

This patient is competent and capable of making his own health decisions. A DNR order and naming a substitute decision-maker apply only when a patient lacks capacity. The next step is to discuss the suspected diagnosis with the patient and explore his preferences.

Toronto Notes 2023 – ELOM, Consent and Capacity:

“Competent patients retain full decision-making authority. Substitute decision-makers are only engaged when the patient lacks capacity. DNR applies to resuscitation, not other medical decisions.”

MCCQE1 Objectives – ELOM > Capacity, Consent, Advance Directives:

“Candidates must recognize that capable patients should be directly involved in decisions. Substitute decision-makers are not invoked unless the patient is incapable.”

Option A implies a breach of confidentiality without permission. Option C is premature. Option D bypasses informed consent. Option E misinterprets the DNR’s scope.

====================================================